Advert Evaluation - Facebook feedback:
I decided to upload both my digipack (see post titled; Digipack Evaluation) and my advert to Facebook, as I feel at the present time it is deemed the most popular social networking site for individuals who are the same age as those within John Mayer's target audience - this became clear after carrying out my prior research.
I asked people I felt fitted into the category above to comment on my advert - telling me what they liked about and what they feel would improve it.
Comment 1 =
" I really like the image, its really bold and eye catching, the effect you have used on image also looks really good. one thing u could change might be the font of the writing, as it could be clearer to read. "
- After reading this, it confirmed my previous opinions of the image being striking and eye-catching, and after reading about the font and it being unclear to read I went back onto Photoshop and made it bolder and therefore easier to read, therefore using the feedback to improve my advert and appeal more to its audience.
Comment 2 =
"excellent use of colour and contrast.I think this cover will appeal to the John Mayer's target audience. love the font style."
- I was pleased to read that this person felt the advert fitted its intended audience and liked the font style.
Comment 3 =
"The picture really illustrates the name of the album , and the picture of the girl looks really good, as her eyes show a lot of sorrow. But the font and the colour is a little difficult to read , but if you made the font of the writing more bold or eye catching it might draw attention from the image."
- This comment states again that the font was difficult to read, therefore again after reading this I made the alterations necessary.
Comment 4 =
"This is well good, although its the same font, much easier to read and the contrast of colour really makes the eye stand out."
- This comment contrasts with comments 1 & 3, regarding how easy the font is to read, although I did also take this into account e.g. that the colours contrast well together ( and therefore didnt change this aspect), but I agreed with the former comments and decided to change the font to make it bolder.
Comment 5 =
"i should have plucked my eyebrows before this shoot :P i love the effect you've used to make the hair look drawn on and the eye looks real. love it :)"
- This comment proves that the effect I applied on Photoshop - Poster Edges, does have an impact on its own and was worth applying as it adds to the advert as a whole.
Comment 6 =
"I love it! I like the font, but maybe make it bolder, so it stands out more?"
- Again this reflects comments 1 & 3 and strengthened my resolve to make the font bolder and stand out more.
Finally, after reading these comments I resolved to make the font bolder and clearer to read but kept the image and image effect the same as it was evident that this aspect was effective in attracting the target audience.
In what ways does your media product use, develop or challenge forms and conventions of real media products?
My advert developed from a wide range of research of various adverts from the same genre as my chosen artist - John Mayer (see post titled: Advert Research) during which I analysed and looked at two different adverts. Piecing together what I felt was effective and noting down what aspects to avoid in my own advert, in this way, it could be said that I used and developed exisiting media products in order to inform and inspire my own product. In terms of challenging the conventions of a real advert, I tried to use an original, unique font that successfully presents the whole theme of the promopack - the handwritten style, made bolder so it is easier to read from a distance, is whimsical and romantic - a direct reflection of our music video.
How effective is the combination of your main product and ancillary texts?
It is essential that the promopack is linked together in some way - for example, the digipack must link with the advert, the advert must link with the music video etc. It is therefore obvious that one must enrich the other and vice versa. I tried to make sure that there was a continuous theme running through all three of my media products - the advert, digipack and music video. This theme was, as stated above, whimsical, romantic and mysterious mixed with some sadness and despair. This theme is present in the images in both my digipack and advert and stills in the video e.g. running make-up, facial expression and colour scheme.
As the digipack, advert and music video exist to promote each other, they must work in accordance with one another. The viewer may first encounter the video and want to buy the single etc. therefore the front of the digipack must link with certain shots in the video, so that they can identify it on the music store shelves easily. This is similar to the relationship between the advert and the digipack - this is why I used the same image on both products in order for them both to be easily identified.
What have you learnt from your audience feedback?
(see above comments & replies in terms of what I learnt from audience feedback, and how I changed/altered the advert to accomodate the comments)
How did you use media technologies in the research, planning, construction and evaluation stages?
In the research stages, I used the internet to look up different adverts from the same genre as John Mayer, I then analysed them in terms of their composition, colours included, typography and image (amongst others). When planning my advert, I drew three flatplans and scanned them into the computer meaning I could therefore comment on them and easily flick between an open window of the scan and the Photoshop window when creating my advert - to get inspiration and remember my original ideas. When constructing my advert, I used the program Photoshop because I already have some experience from Photography AS of using the program and wanted to expand on my priror knowledge. I firstly changed the canvas size to the required size for an advert, then added my original image, went to image adjustments and altered the light/darkness filter and used the effect called Poster Edges to add interest and originality to the image. Then, I used the paintbrush tool to make the left-hand side of the advert black to contrast against the cream coloured font. Finally, during the evaluation stage I uploaded my advert onto facebook and asked people who I felt where in John Mayer's target audience to give me feedback on the advert - telling me what they liked about it and what I could improve. Therefore I could tailor my advert to the target audience - the people who would, in theory, want to buy the product I'm trying to promote.